Specifying the right roofing underlayment is one of those decisions that looks straightforward on paper and gets complicated fast once climate, roof covering type, and code requirements all enter the picture. For roofing contractors and general contractors working across Pennsylvania, the underlayment layer isn’t a formality between the deck and the finish roofing — it’s the secondary line of defense that determines whether a roof survives an ice dam, a wind-driven storm, or a slow leak at a penetration long enough for anyone to notice and fix it. Getting the underlayment category wrong for the roof covering, slope, or climate zone is a common and expensive mistake.
This guide breaks down the three main underlayment categories, where PA code and climate push the decision, and which Core Building Solutions roofing products fit specific roof types.
Roofing Underlayment Categories: Felt, Synthetic, and Self-Adhered
Felt underlayment (traditional asphalt-saturated felt, often called tar paper) has been the industry default for decades. It’s inexpensive and familiar to most crews, but it’s also the least durable option — it tears more easily during installation, absorbs moisture, and degrades faster under UV exposure if left uncovered longer than expected during a project delay.
Synthetic underlayment is a woven or non-woven polymer sheet that has largely replaced felt on new construction and re-roofs. It’s lighter, stronger, more tear-resistant, and holds up significantly better to UV exposure and foot traffic during installation — a real advantage on multi-day or multi-phase roofing projects where the underlayment may be exposed for longer than planned.
Self-adhered (or peel-and-stick) membranes are the highest-performing category, forming a fully adhered, watertight bond to the deck rather than relying on mechanical fasteners alone. These are typically specified for high-risk zones — eaves, valleys, and areas prone to ice damming — where a fastener-only underlayment isn’t sufficient protection against water that backs up under shingles or finds its way through fastener penetrations.
Beyond these three general categories, certain roof coverings require a specialized underlayment engineered for their specific moisture behavior, which is where product selection gets more technical than a generic felt-versus-synthetic comparison.
What PA Code and Climate Push Contractors Toward
Pennsylvania’s building code, based on the IRC and IBC with state amendments through the UCC, requires ice barrier protection at eaves in areas with a history of ice damming — which covers most of the state given PA’s winter climate. That generally means a self-adhered ice-and-water membrane is required from the eave edge to a point at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line, regardless of what underlayment category covers the rest of the roof field.
Beyond the ice barrier requirement, PA’s climate profile — cold winters with freeze-thaw cycling, humid summers, and rainfall spread across the year — makes underlayment choice matter well beyond the code minimum. A felt underlayment that gets soaked during a delayed install and then freezes can degrade before the finish roofing ever goes on. Synthetic underlayments handle that exposure window far better, which is a meaningful advantage on PA projects where weather delays are common. For steep-slope tile and slate roofs, and for metal roofing, the moisture dynamics are different enough from asphalt shingle roofs that a general-purpose underlayment often isn’t the right specification at all.
Underlayment by Roof Covering Type
Asphalt shingle roofs are nailed relatively tight to the underlayment, so moisture management is mostly about resisting bulk water at the surface. Tile and slate roofs behave very differently — they allow air and moisture vapor to flow beneath the roof covering itself, which means the underlayment needs high vapor permeability so that moisture from within an unvented or highly insulated structure can diffuse outward into that ventilated space rather than accumulating against the deck.
Metal roofing and metal-clad façades present yet another moisture profile. Metal panels aren’t sealed to the deck or sheathing, which allows moisture to migrate underneath easily. Left unaddressed, that trapped moisture leads to two separate failure modes: premature damage to the roof substructure, and condensation on the underside of the metal that accelerates corrosion and shortens the panel’s service life.
Core Building Solutions Roofing Products by Roof Type
Core Building Solutions supplies two specialized roofing underlayment products, each engineered for a roof covering with distinct moisture behavior rather than a one-size-fits-all approach.
DELTA®-FOXX is a two-layer, water-resistive underlayment with the highest vapor permeability on the market, purpose-built for tile and slate roofs. Its water-repellent dispersion coating and polyester non-woven substrate resist wind-driven rain and snow while allowing excess moisture within the roof assembly to escape quickly rather than accumulating and damaging insulation or the substructure. It’s Class A fire rated, tear- and scuff-resistant, and designed to stay safe underfoot even when wet — a practical consideration for crews working a steep tile or slate roof over multiple days.
DELTA®-TRELA is a vapor-permeable underlayment built specifically for metal roofs and metal-clad façades. Its 8mm studded fiber mat creates a structured drainage and ventilation course beneath the metal panel, channeling residual moisture to the exterior while the vapor-permeable, watertight fabric layer maintains airtightness. The studded structure also reduces rain and hail noise by up to 15dB — a comfort detail that matters on occupied buildings — and installs in a single step rather than requiring a separate underlayment and separation layer, which keeps project schedules tighter.
Underlayment performance is only as good as the rest of the roof assembly around it, so contractors should also plan flashing and sealant detailing at every valley, penetration, and transition using Core’s broader building envelope line, including our water-resistive barrier products for wall-to-roof transitions on re-roofing and addition projects.
Key Takeaways
Felt, synthetic, and self-adhered membranes cover most standard asphalt shingle applications, with self-adhered ice-and-water membrane required at PA eaves due to ice-damming risk. Tile, slate, and metal roofing all have distinct moisture behavior that calls for a specialized, vapor-permeable underlayment rather than a general-purpose product. Core Building Solutions supplies DELTA®-FOXX for tile and slate applications and DELTA®-TRELA for metal roofing, both engineered around the specific moisture dynamics of those roof coverings.
FAQ
Is synthetic underlayment required by code in Pennsylvania, or is felt still acceptable? PA code doesn’t universally mandate synthetic underlayment across the roof field, but it does require self-adhered ice barrier protection at eaves in ice-dam-prone areas, which covers most of the state. Felt remains code-acceptable in many field applications, though most contractors now prefer synthetic for its durability and UV resistance during installation delays.
Why can’t I use a standard synthetic underlayment under a tile or slate roof? Tile and slate allow air and vapor to move beneath the roof covering in a way asphalt shingles don’t, so the underlayment needs high vapor permeability to let that moisture escape. A standard underlayment not designed for that vapor drive can trap moisture against the deck.
What happens if a metal roof is installed without a proper underlayment like DELTA®-TRELA? Moisture gets trapped underneath the metal panels, leading to premature substructure damage and condensation-driven corrosion on the underside of the panels — both of which shorten the roof’s service life significantly.
How do I know which underlayment fits my specific project? It depends on the roof covering, slope, and how much of the roof falls within the required ice barrier zone. Contact Core Building Solutions to discuss product selection for your upcoming project before you finalize your roofing spec.
Ready to spec the right underlayment for your next roofing project? Contact Core Building Solutions to discuss product selection for your upcoming PA job.

Leave a Reply